Is It Better to Have Bad Credit or No Credit?

By Tevait Feanle •  Updated: 02/19/24 •  5 min read

Credit and credit scores could be one of the most frustrating aspects of our modern financial world. Sometimes it seems like you can’t win unless you have a perfect score. Which very few of us do! Having both bad credit and no credit score at all will impact your ability to access credit products, although in different ways. Today, we will break some of those differences down, and help you get a better understanding of where you stand in the eyes of credit providers. 

- ADVERTISEMENT -

Is It Better to Have Bad Credit or No Credit?

It’s a frustrating answer, we know, but whether it is better to have bad credit or no credit is highly dependent on a variety of factors. Typically, no credit is better than bad credit. Only just, however! Both can be frustrating positions to be in. 

In both cases, you will be seen as a large credit risk that is unappealing to lenders. The difference is that some lenders, depending on the full financial profile they use to assess you, may still be willing to risk lending to someone with no credit history. Especially for smaller amounts, and where other criteria make you look like you will be a responsible user. 

In bad credit cases, they know you have a long record of poor financial habits. You look like a major risk. Until you can show some serious changes in that behavior, most lenders will reject you outright. By that point, you will have rehabilitated your credit score a lot, too. 

Is Bad Credit the Same as No Credit?

Bad credit is not the same as no credit in any way. Let’s break down the differences between the two:

What Can I Get Approved for with No Credit?

Getting approved for credit with no credit is a little easier than with bad credit, but not by much. You won’t get approved for most major loan types. You also won’t be offered high balances initially. About the only things you will be approved for are small balances on credit types with less robust checks and small risk to the lender. This means things like store accounts and some types of credit cards.

- ADVERTISEMENT -

Luckily, once you get started, you will also start building your credit history and things will get easier for the next loan. If you were hoping to jump straight to a car loan or mortgage, however, think again. It won’t happen.

What is the Fastest Way to Build Credit if You Have No Credit?

To build your credit history, you need to access lines of credit and use them responsibly. The catch? Lenders are less likely to give you credit because you have no credit history. It’s a bit of a catch-22 situation. To get started, you need to get approved for your first credit line. 

As we mentioned above, starting small is the best way. You are most likely to get approved for low-stakes, small-sum loans when you have no credit record. The typical advice is to try for a store account (like Truworths) first. Spend a few months using it well and paying it promptly. This will have a small impact on your score, but you can build from there.

Some lenders will offer a low-balance credit card if other factors (such as your income) look good but you lack a credit history. For some products, someone with a credit history can add you as an authorized user, but many products that allow this won’t count it towards your credit history in South Africa. You may also be able to get someone with a good credit history to cosign for you and build your credit that way.  

If you have non-credit financial products, like a utility bill, this has a very minor positive impact on your credit report, but the impact won’t be great. Remember, if you open too many lines of credit at once, this will negatively impact your credit report. Instead, take a slow and steady approach over time. Don’t lose sight of the fact you don’t just need to have credit, but use it responsibly, to build a good credit score. Pay on time and don’t use too much of the credit balance.

Being stuck with no credit record or bad credit is a very frustrating place to be. However, with time, good financial habits, and patience, you will soon be able to fix the situation.

- ADVERTISEMENT -

Keep Reading

Can I Get A Credit Score Report From My Bank?

Can I Get A Credit Score Report From My Bank?

To maintain financial stability and make wise choices, it is crucial to monitor your finances regularly.

What Are the Experian Credit Score Ranges?

What Are the Experian Credit Score Ranges?

This article is written about Experian, which happens to be among the largest and most popular credit bureaus in South Africa.

What is a Bad Credit Score in South Africa?

What is a Bad Credit Score in South Africa?

If you are currently dealing with a low or bad credit score in South Africa, here’s how you can start to fix it. 

How to Get a Free Credit Score Report

How to Get a Free Credit Score Report

Today we will walk you through everything to know about getting your free credit score report, and what your options are. 

Why Your Credit Scores Have Suddenly Dropped

Why Your Credit Scores Have Suddenly Dropped

This article will take you through some of the usual suspects behind a falling credit score and help you prepare to battle them.

How Do Mortgage Lenders Determine Credit Score

How Do Mortgage Lenders Determine Credit Score

Follow us, as we continue to shed some light on mortgage lenders and credit scores. We will take you through how mortgage lenders determine an individual's credit score.

Why is my Credit Score Not Increasing?

Why is my Credit Score Not Increasing?

Today, we will be unpacking some of the reasons that may hinder your credit score’s growth and what you can do about it.

What Does Below-Average Credit Score Mean

What Does Below-Average Credit Score Mean

How do you fix that and what are some of the financial opportunities available for the average credit score bearer? 

How Does Debt Review Affect Credit Score

How Does Debt Review Affect Credit Score

In this blog post, we will analyse how debt review affects credit score, the consequences of debt review in South Africa, and the realities that await your credit score after debt review. 

How Do Credit Scores Work for Married Couples?

How Do Credit Scores Work for Married Couples?

This article explains everything you want to know about how credit scores work for married couples.  

How Is A Business Credit Score Determined?

How Is A Business Credit Score Determined?

How can a business credit score be determined? What is considered a good credit score?

Does Credit Score Affect Your Car Insurance Rate?

Does Credit Score Affect Your Car Insurance Rate?

This article explains all the important aspects of credit scores and how they affect your car insurance rate. 

How to Remove Late Payments From Credit Score

How to Remove Late Payments From Credit Score

How to Remove Late Payments From Credit Score. However, this isn’t always straightforward due to certain rules and procedures.

How To Build A Credit Score As A Student

How To Build A Credit Score As A Student

Several students are left in the dark about what a credit score is or how it helps. This article will bring this crucial topic to light.

What is Required to Check Your Credit Score?

What is Required to Check Your Credit Score?

Today, we will look closer both at the borrower’s side of checking a credit score, and at the lenders